University of Edinburgh Economics Society
The Consilium
Ratione et Consilio
Debate
Should AI be comprehensively regulated?
As AI transforms economies and labour markets, the question of how - and whether - to regulate it has never been more urgent.
The Case For
Regulating Artificial Intelligence: An Economic Imperative
AI generates textbook market failures: negative externalities, information asymmetries, and competitive concentration. The economic case for regulation is strong, and the window for effective action is narrowing.
Eleanor Hughes2 min read
Read the argument→The Case Against
Against AI Regulation: The Innovation Cost We Cannot Afford
Premature AI regulation will entrench incumbents, drive research offshore, and fail to address actual harms. Existing laws are sufficient; targeted enforcement is better than new frameworks.
Alexander Escala2 min read
Read the argument→Read both sides, then cast your vote
Stay Informed
Subscribe to The Consilium
Receive our latest articles and analysis directly in your inbox. Join the conversation on economics, policy, and ideas.
We respect your privacy. Read our Privacy Policy.